Pf. Barnes et al., TUBERCULOSIS TRANSMISSION IN CENTRAL LOS-ANGELES, JAMA, the journal of the American Medical Association, 278(14), 1997, pp. 1159-1163
Context.-Recent studies suggest that many tuberculosis cases in urban
areas result from recent transmission. Delineation of the epidemiologi
c links between patients is important to optimize strategies to reduce
tuberculosis transmission. Objective.-To identify epidemiologic links
among recently infected urban patients with tuberculosis. Design.-Pro
spective evaluation of patients with tuberculosis. Setting.-Central Lo
s Angeles, Calif. Patients.-A total of 162 patients who had culture-pr
oven tuberculosis, Interventions.-Patients were prospectively intervie
wed to identify their contacts and whereabouts. The IS6110-based and p
TBN12-based restriction fragment length polymorphism analyses were per
formed on Mycobacterium tuberculosis isolates. Patients whose isolates
had identical or closely related restriction fragment length polymorp
hism patterns were considered a cluster. Unconditional logistic regres
sion was used to identify independent predictors of clustering. Main O
utcome Measures.-Relationship of clinical and epidemiologic variables
to clustering, Results.-A total of 96 (59%) of 162 patients were in 8
clusters, Only 2 of the 96 clustered patients named others in the clus
ter as contacts, The degree of homelessness was an independent predict
or of clustering, Compared with nonclustered patients, patients in 6 c
lusters were significantly more likely to have spent time at 3 shelter
s and other locations when at least 1 patient in the cluster was conta
gious, and these locations were independent predictors of clustering.
Among nonhomeless persons, clustered patients were significantly more
likely than nonclustered patients to have used daytime services at 3 s
helters, Conclusions.-(1) Traditional contact investigation does not r
eliably identify patients infected with the same M tuberculosis strain
, and (2) locations at which the homeless congregate are important sit
es of tuberculosis transmission for homeless and nonhomeless persons.
Measures that reduce tuberculosis transmission should be based on loca
tions rather than on personal contacts.