Responding to widespread concerns about how scholars typically measure
legislators' ideologies, we propose, implement, and test the efficacy
of a novel measurement approach. We employ formal content analysis of
the news coverage of U.S. Senators' initial campaigns for office to c
reate an ideology scale for members of the 101st Congress. We also off
er systematic tests of reliability and of convergent and discriminant
construct validity for this scale and for conventional, indirect measu
res of Senator ideology using interest group ratings and ''residualize
d analyses'' measures. This newspaper content analysis procedure produ
ces ideology scores that demonstrate high reliability and validity and
that are superior for theory-testing purposes to commonly used surrog
ate or indirect measures of legislator ideology.