Objectives: To review the first 50 patients to receive extracorporeal
membrane oxygenation (ECMO) for respiratory failure at Glenfield Hospi
tal, and to compare them with published series of patients receiving p
ositive pressure ventilation. Design: Retrospective chart review. Sett
ing: Extracorporeal Life Support Organization/European Extracorporeal
Life Support Organization recognized ECMO center. Patients: Fifty cons
ecutive patients referred for ECMO with respiratory failure refractory
to conventional management between 1989 and 1995. Interventions: None
. Measurements and results: Primary end point was survival to hospital
discharge, 66%. Other data (mean and SD): Murray Lung Injury Score, 3
.4 (0.5); ratio of PaO2 to fraction of inspired oxygen, 65 (36.9) mm H
g; duration of ventilation pre-ECMO, 76.5 (83.7 h); peak airway pressu
re, 39.6 (7.4) cm H2O; end-expiratory pressure, 10 (3.3) cm H2O; minut
e ventilation, 12.6 (3.32) L/min; age, 30.1 (10.8) years; duration of
ECMO, 207.4 (177.8) h; and units of blood transfused, 19 (17.3). Survi
val was significantly better than two previously reported series of pa
tients receiving positive pressure ventilation (55.6% and 42% survival
), p=0.036 and p=0.0006. Odds ratio for improved survival was 0.46 (95
% confidence interval, 0.22 to 0.97, p=0.036). Conclusions: Survival w
ith ECMO is 66% for adults with severe respiratory failure. ECMO shoul
d be considered in patients who remain hypoxic despite maximal positiv
e pressure ventilation.