A. Seeber et al., SOLVENT EXPOSURE AND RATINGS OF WELL-BEING - DOSE-EFFECT RELATIONSHIPS AND CONSISTENCY OF DATA, Environmental research, 73(1-2), 1997, pp. 81-91
Ratings on analog scales for dimensions of wellbeing provide informati
on about the acute state of well-being during solvent exposure. In a s
tudy of volunteers and workers exposed to solvents, tension, tiredness
, complaints, and annoyance were rated on seven-point scales. Dose-eff
ect relationships were analyzed for several scenarios; data were colle
cted in diaries during work hours. In two studies, 40 volunteers in an
exposure laboratory were exposed to ethanol by inhalation at levels b
etween 80 and 1900 parts per million (ppm). In two other studies, 32 v
olunteers were exposed to acetone and ethyl acetate in single exposure
s (1000 and 500 ppm, respectively) and combined exposures (500 ppm ace
tone + 200 ppm ethyl acetate). A field study of 8 exposed workers and
8 nonexposed controls involved exposures of up to 2100 ppm acetone. Do
se-effect relationships were shown for ratings of annoyance by correla
tions of 0.36 (ethanol) and 0.58 (acetone). Similar coefficients were
found for ratings of complaints. The dimensions tension and tiredness
showed no stable relationship with exposure. The consistency of rating
s was assessed by means of correlations between the ratings given duri
ng periods of nearly equal exposures. Ratings of annoyance for the dif
ferent studies between the periods of nearly equal exposure showed ave
rage correlations from 0.68 to 0.84. For the ratings of complaints, th
e coefficients were 0.53 to 0.81. The coefficients for tension had sim
ilar stabilities; those for tiredness were lower. (C) 1997 Academic Pr
ess.