Dm. Bishop et B. Kirtman, MOLECULAR FIRST HYPERPOLARIZABILITY OF PUSH-PULL POLYENES - RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN ELECTRONIC AND VIBRATIONAL CONTRIBUTION BY A 2-STATE MODEL- COMMENT, Physical review. B, Condensed matter, 56(4), 1997, pp. 2273-2274
Castiglioni, Del Zoppo, and Zerbi [Phys:. Rev. B 53, 13 319 (1996)] ha
ve developed a theory that attempts to demonstrate the equality (or ne
ar equality) of electronic and vibrational first hyperpolarizabilities
in push-pull polyenes. In this Comment we draw attention to a serious
flaw in their argument.