Cp. An et F. Luty, UNIVERSAL 2-STATE REORIENTATIONAL DYNAMICS OF DIATOMIC HYDRIDES IN FCC SALT CRYSTALS - COMMENT, Physical review. B, Condensed matter, 56(10), 1997, pp. 6345-6347
In a recent paper, Mungan et al. [Phys. Rev. B 54, 9204 (1996)] have p
roposed a model of ''universal two-state reorientational dynamics of d
iatomic hydrides in fee salt crystals,'' based experimentally on an ob
served disappearance of librational ir absorption around 150 K. For th
e only presented example of OH- defects in RbCl hosts, we show by comp
arison to our measurements that this claimed disappearance is not vali
d even up to T=350 K. Moreover, we show by accurate spectral data of t
wo other examples (OH- and OD- in KBr) that the claimed universal vali
dity of the proposed ''thermally activated jump-rotational-diffusion m
odel'' is not true for OH- and OD- fcc alkali-chloride and bromide cry
stals and that there is no contrast to the OH-/OD- dynamic behavior in
bcc CsCl hosts.