M. Tuttleman et al., A CROSS-SECTIONAL ASSESSMENT OF HEALTH-STATUS INSTRUMENTS IN PATIENTSWITH RHEUMATOID-ARTHRITIS PARTICIPATING IN A CLINICAL-TRIAL, Journal of rheumatology, 24(10), 1997, pp. 1910-1915
Objective. To (I) validate die Short-Form Health Sun ey (SF-36) as a g
eneric functional health status measure in patients with rheumatoid ar
thritis CRA), and (2) assess correlations between the SF-36 and other
outcome measures used in tile Minocycline in Rheumatoid Arthritis (MIR
A) Trial. Methods, We conducted a cross sectional analysis of the fina
l visit outcome measures from the 48 week, multicenter; placebo contro
lled double blind MIRA trial. Multitrait scaling analyses assessed con
vergent and discriminant validity and internal consistency reliability
of the SF-36 in the study patients. Responses to comparable items on
the SF-36 and modified Health Assessment Questionnaire (M-HAQ) regardi
ng physical functioning were compared and questions from both instrume
nts were also compared to other RA outcome measures, Results. In patie
nts with RA, the SF-36 had high internal consistency and reliability,
high discriminant and high convergent validity. Moderate correlations
were observed (r = -0.46 to -0.61, p < 0.01 in each case) for comparab
le items on the SF-36 and M-HAQ regarding dressing, walking, and bendi
ng, Joint tenderness score correlations with items on the M-HAQ and SF
-36, and joint tenderness score correlations with the SF-36 scales wer
e higher than for joint swelling scores. Physician and patient global
assessments were mast highly correlated (r = 0.58 and 0.66, p < 0.01,
respectively) with the SF-36 bodily pain item. Conclusion. The SF-36 i
s a valid Instrument for this RA population. The SF-36 correlates with
the M-HAQ and the physician and patient global assessments, The usefu
lness of tile SF-36 in measuring change in RA clinical trials requires
testing in longitudinal studies.