Re. Chapin et al., THE RELATIONSHIPS AMONG REPRODUCTIVE END-POINTS IN SWISS MICE, USING THE REPRODUCTIVE ASSESSMENT BY CONTINUOUS BREEDING DATABASE, Fundamental and applied toxicology, 38(2), 1997, pp. 129-142
The database of Continuous Breeding mouse studies was evaluated to det
ermine the relationships between the functional indicators of reproduc
tion (pup measures) and the various necropsy endpoints collected for m
ales and females. Of 72 chemicals studied, both males and females were
affected in 33 studies, while females and/or conceptuses were affecte
d in 7, Two compounds affected only males, 17 studies were negative, a
nd in 13 studies with effects it was not possible to clearly determine
the affected gender(s), Greater F-0 dam weight was correlated with in
creased pup mass per litter; this relationship was strongest for the f
irst litter, and weakest for the fifth litter. For both generations of
treated females (F-0 and F-1), longer estrous cycles correlated with
reduced numbers of pups; the relationship was stronger in F-0 than in
F( )females and was not seen in controls. Sperm parameters had differe
nt distributions in treated mice than in control mice. Fertility (tota
l live pups/number of pairs cohabited) was reduced if there were > sim
ilar to 15% sperm abnormalities or if sperm motility (moving/ not movi
ng) was < approximate to 37%. Both of these relationships appeared to
have thresholds. Epididymal sperm count in treated animals, however, w
as linearly related to fertility, even within the control range, sugge
sting strongly that other factors are important. Using both treated an
d control data together, combining sperm count with motility could exp
lain much (r = 0.77) of the variation in fertility; adding morphology
did not significantly improve the correlation, The model was almost as
strong using count and morphology, in which case adding motility did
not strengthen the model, This analysis of these studies shows that wh
ile some endpoints (e.g., random-estrous-cycle-point ovary weight) cor
relate poorly with fertility, other necropsy endpoints (epididymal spe
rm count and motility, estrous cycle length, and testis and epididymal
weights) can be useful (though not complete) surrogates of overall re
productive function, Indeed, over many studies, epididymal sperm count
in treated animals correlates with fertility so well that even small
reductions (approximate to 20%) in count result in reduced fertility,
suggesting that mice may be better models of human fertility than was
previously believed. (C) 1997 Society of Toxicology.