Soil water is the main factor influencing forage production in the sem
iarid Northern Great Plains. Developing germplasm that uses limited wa
ter more efficiently would benefit forage production for hay and lives
tock grazing. Development of selection criteria suited to screening la
rge breeding populations for water-use efficiency (WUE) are needed to
enhance this effort. This study evaluated carbon isotope discriminatio
n (Delta), tissue ash concentration, and canopy temperature of populat
ions of diploid crested wheatgrass (Agropyron cristatum L.), tetraploi
d crested wheatgrass [A. desertorum (Fisch. ex. Link) Schult.], and we
stern wheatgrass [Pascopyrum smithii (Rybd.) Love] to determine the ut
ility of using ash concentration and canopy temperature as alternative
criteria to Delta for selecting plants with high WUE. Tissue ash conc
entration, canopy temperature, and Delta were measured on half-sib fam
ilies from genetically broad-based populations of each species across
two field growing seasons. Sufficient genetic variation was present fo
r Delta and ash concentration among families within each species to su
ggest possible use of these traits as criteria for selecting plants wi
th higher WUE. Differences in canopy temperature among families were p
resent only in 1994. Correlations between ash and Delta were greatest
for tetraploid crested wheatgrass and least for western wheatgrass. Co
rrelation of canopy temperature with Delta was significant for tetrapl
oid crested wheatgrass both years and for diploid crested wheatgrass i
n 1993, but neither year for western wheatgrass. Ash concentration and
Delta were moderately heritable in all three grass populations, indic
ating that both traits are under genetic control and could likely be a
ltered through breeding. Using ash and canopy temperature as criteria
for selecting plants with greater WUE would provide a relatively low-c
ost, simple approach to develop cultivars with improved WUE.