J. Saintaubin et M. Poirier, THE INFLUENCE OF WORD FUNCTION IN THE MISSING-LETTER EFFECT - FURTHEREVIDENCE FROM FRENCH, Memory & cognition, 25(5), 1997, pp. 666-676
When asked to detect target letters while reading continuous text, sub
jects miss more letters in highly common function words than in less c
ommon content words. This known as the missing-letter effect. Accordin
g to the structural account, the higher omission rates for frequent fu
nction words are attributable to their role in supporting the extracti
on of phrase structure, after which they become lost in the transition
from structure to meaning. This implies that word function in and of
itself should affect letter detection accuracy. This issue was examine
d in four experiments while controlling for a number of confounded fac
tors associated with another influential model: the unitization accoun
t. The first experiment extended the missing-letter effect to the Fren
ch language. The second showed that letter detection is influenced by
slight variations in the function assumed by the same word, such as wh
en it is used as a definite article as opposed to a pronoun. This effe
ct was observed even when the frequency of the orthographic pattern an
d the syllable stress patterns were controlled. In the last two experi
ments, a control was added for another factor: frequency of word meani
ng. The results indicate that word function contributes to the missing
-letter effect over and above what is contributed by frequency of word
meaning.