No. Renno et al., RADIATIVE-CONVECTIVE MODEL WITH AN EXPLICIT HYDROLOGIC-CYCLE .1. FORMULATION AND SENSITIVITY TO MODEL PARAMETERS, JOURNAL OF GEOPHYSICAL RESEARCH-ATMOSPHERES, 99(D7), 1994, pp. 14429-14441
A hydrological cycle is explicitly included in a one-dimensional radia
tive-convective equilibrium model which is coupled to a ''swamp'' surf
ace and tested with various cumulus convection schemes: the hard and s
oft convective adjustment schemes, the Kuo scheme, the Goddard Institu
te for Space Studies (GISS) (1974) model 1 scheme, the GISS (1983) mod
el 2 scheme, and the Emanuel scheme. The essential difference between
our model and other radiative-convective models is that in our model t
he moisture profile (but not cloudiness) is interactively computed by
the cumulus convection scheme. This has a crucial influence on the com
putation of the radiative fluxes throughout the atmosphere and therefo
re on the model's sensitivities. Using the Emanuel scheme, we show tha
t the climate equilibrium is very sensitive to cloud microphysical pro
cesses. Clouds with high precipitation efficiency produce cold and dry
climates. Clouds with low precipitation efficiency lead to moist and
warm climates. Since climate equilibrium can be very sensitive to the
cloud microphysical processes, any cumulus convection scheme adequate
for use in general circulation models (GCMs) should be strongly based
on them. The cumulus convection schemes currently in use in GCMs bypas
s the microphysical processes by making arbitrary moistening assumptio
ns. We suggest that they are inadequate for climate change studies.