Rj. Meyer et al., AN AUDIT OF THE ASSESSMENT AND MANAGEMENT OF ADULTS ADMITTED TO CHRISTCHURCH-HOSPITAL WITH COMMUNITY-ACQUIRED PNEUMONIA, New Zealand medical journal, 110(1052), 1997, pp. 349-352
Aims. To audit the management of adult patients admitted with communit
y acquired pneumonia including the standards of clinical assessment, u
se of modified British Thoracic Society prognostic criteria and antibi
otic therapy. Methods. A prospective, 16 week, study of consecutive pa
tients admitted to Christchurch Hospital with community acquired pneum
onia. Results. Ninety-six patients met the inclusion criteria. The med
ian age was 70 years. A pathogen was identified in 28 (26%) patients.
Forty two patients fulfilled the modified British Thoracic Society cri
teria for severe disease and all 9 deaths occurred in that subgroup. T
he management guidelines were followed without exception in only 15% o
f cases. Documentation of the prognostic criteria was often incomplete
and therefore only 33% of those patients with severe disease were cor
rectly identified. Seventy one percent of those with severe disease we
re treated with only one antibiotic and there was significant delay in
administering the first dose in 44% of cases. A follow up chest radio
graph was performed in 43 (51%) of those discharged. Conclusions. Ther
e was poor compliance with the management guidelines. There was a lack
of awareness of the severity criteria leading to inadequate treatment
in many cases. Further educational initiatives are indicated.