Ca. Ribic et al., SCALE-RELATED SEABIRD-ENVIRONMENTAL RELATIONSHIPS IN PACIFIC EQUATORIAL WATERS, WITH REFERENCE TO EL-NINO SOUTHERN-OSCILLATION EVENTS, Marine ecology. Progress series, 156, 1997, pp. 183-203
We assessed the spatial scales at which variability in ocean climate c
ould affect habitat associations of tropical seabirds and whether spec
ies-environmental variable relationships at the smallest scale provide
insight into occurrence patterns at larger scales. In the eastern tro
pical Pacific (10 degrees N to 10 degrees S and 140 degrees to 90 degr
ees W), seabirds were censused on 16 cruises that followed the same tr
acks every spring and autumn, 1984 to 1991. This study area possesses
closely spaced, well-defined water types and the time period was suffi
cient to include 2 ENSOs (El Nino-Southern Oscillation) and 1 cold wat
er event (LNSO), thus insuring maximum environmental variability. On t
he cruises, we measured physical features such as sea-surface temperat
ure (SST) and salinity (SSS) at a coarse scale (1 to 100 km) as well a
s, at the large scale, the identity of surface water masses and curren
t systems. During spring, at the coarse scale, seabirds were associate
d mainly with a canonical axis consisting of SST and SSS. During autum
n, coarse scale seabird/environment associations were defined by a can
onical axis composed of SST and thermocline depth; SSS was of secondar
y importance. Using SST and SSS optima from the coarse scale analysis,
we could predict only the water mass associations for individual spec
ies during spring. Consistent between-year associations with water mas
ses were not found in either season. Regardless of season, seabirds at
the large scale were associated most consistently with current system
s rather than water masses. At the coarse scale, neither the canonical
axes nor the seabird associations with these axes were affected by EN
SO/LNSO events. At the large scale, seabird associations with currents
remained the same during the ENSO/LNSO events for sooty tern, black-w
inged and white-winged petrels, and wedge-tailed shearwater. Juan Fern
andez petrel, wedge-rumped storm-petrel, and Leach's storm-petrel had
different associations with currents during the ENSO/LNSO events. We h
ypothesize that the effect of ENSO/LNSO events on individual species i
s mitigated by the ability of species to persist in low productivity w
aters during the non-ENSO/LNSO years.