Li. Remennick et Ra. Shtarkshall, TECHNOLOGY VERSUS RESPONSIBILITY - IMMIGRANT PHYSICIANS FROM THE FORMER SOVIET-UNION REFLECT ON ISRAELI HEALTH-CARE, Journal of health and social behavior, 38(3), 1997, pp. 191-202
About 13,000 physicians from the former Soviet Union have found themse
lves in the saturated medical market in Israel as a result of the late
st wave of immigration. This paper examines the gap in professional at
titudes and practices between Israeli and Soviet MDs and the cognitive
mechanisms employed by immigrant physicians in the process of adjustm
ent to the new medical culture. The study draws on 25 semistructured i
nterviews with recent (about three years in Israel) immigrant doctors
who were at various stages of obtaining a local medical license. Refle
cting on the need to redefine themselves as professionals and to confr
ont negative stereotypes regarding ex-Soviet doctors, many respondents
stressed the strong sides of Soviet medical training and work style.
In their collective self-portrait, immigrant doctors emphasized devoti
on to patients, clinical intuition, manual skills, and empathy, while
flaws were regarded as superficial and improvable by technical trainin
g. Conversely, the alleged flaws of Israeli doctors were perceived by
these informants as pertaining to the core of medicine: ''Excessive de
pendence on technology,'' ''lack of responsibility toward patients, ''
and ''weak preventive orientation'' of Israeli colleagues were repeat
edly criticized. The paper sheds light on the significant conceptual d
ifferences between the Soviet and Western medical traditions and provi
des a vivid example of the sociocultural construction of medicine. Our
findings are also indicative of the interpretative processes and copi
ng strategies that immigrants in general may develop in saturated prof
essional markets.