C. Haasen et al., PSYCHIATRIC-DISORDERS AMONG MIGRANTS IN GERMANY - PREVALENCE IN A PSYCHIATRIC CLINIC AND IMPLICATIONS FOR SERVICES AND RESEARCH, European psychiatry, 12(6), 1997, pp. 305-310
Past studies examining the prevalence of psychiatric disorders among m
igrants have described a higher rate of schizophrenia, whereas the onl
y major German study found a lower rate. Considering the changed compo
sition of migrants today, a new assessment has become necessary. All a
dmission records of migrants to a psychiatric clinic in 1993 and 1994
were assessed for diagnosis, symptomatology and treatment. Two hundred
sixty-three migrant admissions, 8.4% of total admissions, were assess
ed. Of these 41.4% received a diagnosis of a schizophrenic disorder, s
ignificantly more than other clinic patients. The mean age at admissio
n was 33.8 years, at onset of illness 28.6 years and at time of migrat
ion 20.3 years. Only 7.9% were mentally ill at the time of migration.
Of those with psychotic and depressive symptoms at admission, 70% rece
ived a diagnosis of a schizophrenic disorder and 78% were treated with
antipsychotics. Antidepressants were prescribed only to 47% of those
with a diagnosis of a depressive disorder and only 33% of those with d
epressive and no psychotic symptoms. An underrepresentation of migrant
s shows differences in the use of psychiatric services. The higher rat
e of schizophrenia may be due to misdiagnosis, an artifactual effect o
f underrepresentation of other disorders or an actual higher rate amon
g migrants. The reluctance to use antidepressants underlines the neces
sity of training, so as not to withhold treatment options due to cultu
ral barriers.