Cf. Chi et Cl. Chen, DIFFERENTIAL THRESHOLD OF LENGTH AND RESPONSE CRITERION FOR INSPECTING IRREGULAR OBJECTS, Perceptual and motor skills, 85(2), 1997, pp. 723-735
This research investigated human visual sensitivity and bias in inspec
ting irregular objects. A preliminary study was conducted using the me
thod of constants to determine the threshold value for judgment of siz
e. A factorial experiment was conducted using payoffs, rate of defecti
ve items, and detectability in the signal-detection theory as the fact
ors. In total, eight experimental conditions were tested. 10 college s
tudents were recruited as subjects. Each subject was asked to compare
40 teapot shapes to a standard teapot shape under eight experimental c
onditions. Defective shapes were generated by lengthening the vertical
dimension of a standard teapot shape by a factor of 1.01 and 1.04 for
'low' and 'high' detectability. The decision lime and responses of 'i
dentical' or 'different' were collected under all experimental conditi
ons. Analysis indicates that the decision-making strategy used to insp
ect this irregular object was very close to maximizing the accuracy of
decision-making by considering the rare of defective items. This resu
lt is different from most research findings in signal-detection theory
in which responses of human beings are similar to degraded Bayes opti
mizers. The standard deviation of the signal distribution was about 1.
30 and 1.41 limes that of the noise distributions for 'low' and 'high'
detectability.