Em. Bitzer et al., HOSPITAL OUTCOMES RESEARCH IN GERMANY - RESULTS FROM A RETROSPECTIVE SURVEY AMONG SICKNESS FUND BENEFICIARIES, Medical care, 35(10), 1997, pp. 112-122
OBJECTIVES. The authors assess the feasibility of using retrospective,
indication-specific patient surveys to conduct hospital outcomes rese
arch in Germany. Surgical outcome and patient satisfaction were examin
ed in patients who underwent common elective surgical procedures. METH
ODS. Using the International Classification of Diseases Ninth Revision
coding available in the Schwabisch Gmund health insurance data base,
all patients for a defined period of time with one of the three follow
ing diagnoses were selected and questioned retrospectively using an in
dication-specific survey instrument: (1) varicose veins of the lower e
xtremity; (2) nasal septum deviation; and (3) inner knee joint damage
limited to patients undergoing arthroscopic meniscus repair: Survey co
ntent focused on preoperative conditions, pre-and postoperative sympto
ms, postoperative complications, the nature and duration of postoperat
ive follow-up, and satisfaction with surgical outcome. RESULTS. Signif
icant postoperative improvement of preoperative symptoms was found for
all three groups. Complete freedom from symptoms was found in 29.7% o
f patients treated for varicose veins, 24.1% of patients with meniscus
repair, and in only 10.6% of patients with nasal septum deviation. Mu
ltivariate analyses indicated that postoperative impairment was the de
cisive variable governing patient satisfaction for all three groups. C
ONCLUSIONS. The use of retrospective, indication-specific patient surv
eys constitutes a time-efficient, cost-effective, and patient-focused
option for the systematic acquisition and evaluation of health outcome
s in Germany. This methodology holds promise for international and dom
estic efforts to demonstrate the consequences of restructuring activit
ies in the inpatient sector.