S. Sinclair et al., INTRAOPERATIVE INTRAVASCULAR VOLUME OPTIMIZATION AND LENGTH OF HOSPITAL STAY AFTER REPAIR OF PROXIMAL FEMORAL FRACTURE - RANDOMIZED CONTROLLED TRIAL, BMJ. British medical journal, 315(7113), 1997, pp. 909-912
Objectives: To assess whether intraoperative intravascular volume opti
misation improves outcome and shortens hospital stay after repair of p
roximal femoral fracture. Design: Prospective, randomised controlled t
rial comparing conventional intraoperative fluid management with repea
ted colloid fluid challenges monitored by oesophageal Doppler ultrason
ography to maintain maximal stroke Volume throughout die operative per
iod. Setting: Teaching hospital, London. Subjects: 40 patients undergo
ing repair of proximal femoral fracture under general anaesthesia. Int
erventions: Patients were randomly assigned to receive either conventi
onal intraoperative fluid management (control patients) or additional
repeated colloid fluid challenges with oesophageal Doppler ultrasonogr
aphy used to maintain maximal stroke volume throughout the operative p
eriod (protocol patients). Main outcome measures: Time declared medica
lly fit for hospital discharge, duration of hospital stay (in acute be
d; in acute plus long stay bed), mortality, perioperative haemodynamic
changes. Results: Intraoperative intravascular fluid loading produced
significantly greater changes in stroke Volume (median 15 ml (95% con
fidence interval 10 to 21 ml)) and cardiac output (1.2 l/min (0.1 to 2
.3 l/min)) than in the conventionally managed group (-5 ml (-10 to 1 m
i) and -0.4 l/min (-1.0 to 0.2 l/min)) (P < 0.001 and P < 0.05, respec
tively). One protocol patient and two control patients died in hospita
l. In the survivors, postoperative recovery was significantly faster i
n the protocol patients, with shorter times to being declared medicall
y fit for discharge (median 10 (9 to 15) days v 15 (11 to 40) days, P
< 0.05) and a 39% reduction in hospital stay (12 (8 to 13) days v 20 (
10 to 61) days, P < 0.05). Conclusions: Proximal femoral fracture repa
ir constitutes surgery in a high risk population. Intraoperative intra
vascular volume loading-to optimal stroke volume resulted in a more ra
pid postoperative recovery and a significantly reduced hospital stay.