Asthma is a chronic inflammatory disorder of the airways that affects
10 to 17.5 million people and leads to more than $5 billion in treatme
nt costs in the United States annually This retrospective study is an
initial step in understanding the beneficial economic outcomes of inha
led corticosteroid therapy by determining whether differences exist in
healthcare utilization expenditures for three inhaled corticosteroids
available for use in the United States: (1) beclomethasone dipropiona
te (Vanceril(R)/Schering and Beclovent(R)/Allan & Hanburys); (2) fluni
solide (Aerobid(R)/Forest); and (3) and triamcinolone acetonide (Azmac
ort(R)/Rhone-Poulenc Rorer). The study was based on an analysis of 4,4
41 patients with at least one pharmaceutical claim for one of the stud
y drugs, using inpatient, outpatient, and prescription drug claims dat
a obtained from The MEDSTAT Group's MarketScan(R) database for calenda
r years 1990 through 1993. We tested a null hypothesis for no differen
ces in total asthma treatment costs, when drugs were excluded, using m
ultivariate linear regression modeling controlling for patient demogra
phic and clinical characteristics that might affect the study outcome.
We found that, after excluding study drug payments and controlling fo
r other contributing factors, total asthma healthcare expenditures for
triamcinolone acetonide (Azmacort) users were higher than those for b
eclomethasone dipropionate (Vanceril and Beclovent) and flunisolide (A
erobid) users. When study drug costs were included in the expenditure
measure, both triamcinolone acetonide (Azmacort) and flunisolide (Aero
bid) users had higher expenditures than did beclomethasone dipropionat
e (Vanceril and Beclovent) users. No significant differences in expend
itures were detected between Vanceril and Beclovent patients, a findin
g consistent with the fact that these drugs are the same type of inhal
ed corticosteroid. Other factors contributing to differences in total
asthma healthcare costs included patient age, patterns of switching am
ong and continuing with study drugs, prestudy asthma utilization or dr
ug proxy severity, and comorbidities or Precipitating illnesses.