R. Michard, QUANTITATIVE MORPHOLOGY OF E-SO GALAXIES .4. ELLIPTICALS AND LENTICULARS AS A SINGLE POPULATION, Astronomy and astrophysics, 288(2), 1994, pp. 401-412
The geometrical properties of E and SO galaxies have been intercompare
d using the data collected in Paper III (Michard & Marchal 1994) for 1
08 RSA objects in a complete, luminosity and distance limited, sample.
As the apparent flattening (largely an effect of projection along the
line of sight), is a determining factor in the segregation between E
and SO objects, the working hypothesis has been made that an important
bias is introduced in the recognition of the two classes. It is perha
ps as well to assume that galaxies of both Hubble types belong, but fo
r a small(?) minority, to a common population of objects with similar
structures. This hypothesis receives strong support from the frequency
-diagrams of the ellipticity epsilon(max) measured near its maximum or
at the isophote of surface brightness V=21.5. The diagram for S0's al
one cannot be generated by the random projection of any objects: it is
clearly biased by the shift to the E type of many S0's of moderate in
clination and relatively modest disk. This limits the significance of
the same diagrams for E galaxies. The noted bias is much reduced if SO
's and disky E's are considered together. Because of the strong outwar
ds decrease of the ellipticities in disky E's and in the SO's with non
-thin envelopes (thick disks and spheroidal haloes), the frequency dia
grams of the ellipticities measured at the classical B=25, or at V=25,
do not show the bias noted above for SO's. The lack of round E's requ
ires the spheroidal components to be faintly triaxial, as recently emp
hasized by other authors. Our hypothesis is also supported by the over
lap of E and SO galaxies in ad hoc classification schemes of elliptici
ty profiles and envelope geometry, and in such correlation diagrams as
: the ellipticity in the envelope, i.e. near mu(V)=25, against the int
ermediate maximum ellipticity the extremum of the Carter's coefficient
e4 (or a4 or c4 in other similar works) against the maximum elliptici
ty the disk extent, as far as it can be estimated without detailed mod
eling, against the maximum ellipticity. The ''standard'' structure of
E - SO objects includes a spheroidal, nearly oblate component, that ca
nnot be of constant ellipticity: this parameter often increases outwar
ds from its bulge value, then decreases again in the envelope. Disks o
f various brightness and extent, between dominating and vanishing, are
the second essential component. Obviously, their relative importance
is , together with the dust content, a physical criterion involved in
the morphological separation between E and SO objects, besides the inc
lination effect. In the present sample, the disk cannot be detected in
nearly half of E classified objects, and is probably vanishing in abo
ut 40% of this class, or circa 17% of the total of studied early-type
objects. This minority contains mostly boxy E's with nonstandard ellip
ticity profiles, and, as is well known, no significant rotational supp
ort. From the convergent results of quantitative morphology and kinema
tics, the early-type galaxies should be segregated into the majority c
lass of disky fast oblate rotators and a minority class of non-rotatin
g ellipsoids.