Ik. Khabibrakhmanov et Dj. Mullan, GRAVITATIONAL DAMPING OF ALFVEN WAVES IN STELLAR ATMOSPHERES AND WINDS - RESPONSE, The Astrophysical journal, 488(2), 1997, pp. 898-900
The preceding comment by J. V. Hollweg presents criticisms of a paper
that had reported estimates of the damping rates of Alfven waves in th
e presence of gravitational acceleration. Here we point out that there
is actually significant overlap between the conclusions of the former
and the latter. We agree with a new point raised by the comment conce
rning up/down asymmetry of gravity damping.