S. Sillman et al., THE USE OF PHOTOCHEMICAL INDICATORS TO EVALUATE OZONE-NOX-HYDROCARBONSENSITIVITY - CASE-STUDIES FROM ATLANTA, NEW-YORK, AND LOS-ANGELES, Journal of the Air & Waste Management Association [1995], 47(10), 1997, pp. 1030-1040
This study examines the use of ambient measurements of a number of ''p
hotochemical indicators'' as a basis for determining ozone-NOx-hydroca
rbon sensitivity and for evaluating the performance of ozone models. T
he successful photochemical indicators are: O-3/NOy, O-3/NOz (where NO
z = NOy-NOx), O-3/HNO3, H2O2/HNO3, and H2O2/NOz. Results of Urban Airs
hed Model (UAM-IV) simulations for Atlanta, GA, New York, NY, and Los
Angeles, CA, show that high values of these species ratios are correla
ted with NOx-sensitive chemistry and low values are associated with re
active organic gases (ROG)-sensitive chemistry. Correlations between m
easured O-3 and NOy in Atlanta and between O-3 and NOz in Los Angeles
are consistent with theory and reflect the difference between likely N
Ox-sensitive chemistry in Atlanta and hydrocarbon-sensitive chemistry
in Los Angeles. Measured O-3, NOx, and NOy are used to evaluate model
performance during two air pollution events in Atlanta and Los Angeles
. The performance evaluation includes model scenarios for each city wi
th different anthropogenic and biogenic emission rates and different N
Ox-ROG sensitivity predictions. Simulations with different NOx-ROG che
mistry are found to give similar predictions for peak ozone but differ
ent values for photochemical indicators. Comparison with measured valu
es of photochemical indicators provides a more stringent test of model
performance than evaluation versus observed ozone.