For both SiAl zeolites and SAPOs, the protons belong to bridging hydro
xyls in the Si-OH-Al, species. To make a comparison possible, the acid
sites are described by the environment of Si atoms in such a moiety.
It is shown that in SiAl zeolites and in SAPOs, the occupation by Al,
Si, or P of the first and second shell of tetrahedra around a central
Si atom governs the acid strength through the electronegativity of ato
ms and the connectivity of tetrahedras. In SAPOs, the strength of acid
ity increases first, as the first layer contains more Si, and, second,
as the second layer is richer in P. Since Si-O-P bonds are, not likel
y, the addition of Si above an upper limit depending on the structure
type tends to generate siliceous islands. This increases the acid stre
ngth by forming Si (nAl) species, with n < 4, at the border of the isl
ands. The number of species and the value of n depend on the size of t
he islands, itself directly related to the Si content and to the conne
ctivity of tetrahedra, i.e., to the topology of the structure. The for
mation of pure Si islands decreases the expected number of protons per
Si. A correlation is described in both SiAl zeolites and SAPOs betwee
n the ranking of acid strengths and the chemical shift of Si-29 in MAS
n.m.r. when the type and number of first and second neighbors (Al, Si
, or P) is changing.