Cs. Pickles et al., DETERMINATION OF HIGH-SPATIAL-RESOLUTION ARGON ISOTOPE VARIATIONS IN METAMORPHIC BIOTITES, Geochimica et cosmochimica acta, 61(18), 1997, pp. 3809-3833
The circumstances of preservation of relict metamorphic minerals and f
abrics which have subsequently been involved in later metamorphic cycl
es remain enigmatic because the kinetic parameters are not well unders
tood. Textures and chemistry cannot always give direct information on
the conditions attained in the successive events. We show in this stud
y that Ar-40/Ar-39 laser studies can, in contrast, provide thermal his
tory determinations and successfully discriminate between geological m
odels. Two samples have been examined from the Seconda Zona Diorito Ki
nzigitica (IIDK) of the Sesia Zone, Italian Alps. A unit which preserv
es relict Hercynian metamorphic assemblages and is now located structu
rally above rocks which preserve Alpine eclogite and greenschist facie
s assemblages. The circumstances of this preservation remain controver
sial, with proposed models falling into two main categories. One hypot
hesis advocates that the IIDK was juxtaposed into its present position
late in the Alpine orogeny and experienced no significant heating eve
nt. Alternatively the IIDK has been in its present position for the du
ration of the Alpine orogenic cycle and has been exposed to high tempe
ratures but due to sluggish reaction kinetics, it failed to reequilibr
ate and develop Alpine metamorphic minerals. A high spatial resolution
Ar-40/Ar-39 study using the ultraviolet laser ablation microprobe (UV
LAMP) technique was undertaken with the aims of reassessing the metamo
rphic history of the IIDK and investigating the behavior of argon with
in the unit during its thermal evolution. 128 analyses have been obtai
ned from ten profiles, between 60 and 275 mu m long, across biotite gr
ains which show apparent ages ranging from 514 to 161 Ma within indivi
dual crystals. These apparent age variations are systematic according
to location in the grain, with the oldest ages at the grain edges and
the youngest in the cores. These apparent age variations can not be ex
plained by chemical alteration and require diffusion of excess argon i
nto the grains, The age profiles show a remarkable fit to theoreticall
y derived curves for volume diffusion of argon. Time integrated diffus
ion values obtained for the profiles fall between 2 X 10(-6) cm(2) and
5 X 10(-6) cm(2); this variation is interpreted as being due to spati
al and temporal fluctuations in the availability of argon from the gra
in boundary network. Diffusion, and hence profile development, initiat
ed at different times within the biotites, consequently producing the
range of time integrated diffusion values. The temperatures at which t
he profiles developed have been estimated using published biotite diff
usion parameters to model possible thermal histories. Using the assump
tions of either a short thermal pulse event or continuous cooling from
high temperatures, the models suggest that the profiles developed at
temperatures less than 300 degrees C. Possible geological models are p
roposed which document the thermal and excess argon history of the IID
K from the Hercynian through to the Alpine orogeny. The study shows th
e key role of detailed argon isotope studies in assessing the thermal
evolution of rocks with relict metamorphic assemblages. Copyright (C)
1997 Elsevier Science Ltd.