Bl. Gulson et al., SOURCE AND PATHWAYS OF LEAD IN HUMANS FROM THE BROKEN-HILL MINING COMMUNITY - AN ALTERNATIVE USE OF EXPLORATION METHODS, Economic geology and the bulletin of the Society of Economic Geologists, 89(4), 1994, pp. 889-908
To assist in recommendations for the most suitable lead abatement poli
cies in Broken Hill, New South Wales, Australia, knowledge of the sour
ces and pathways of the lead into humans is critical. We have approach
ed these problems using the lead isotope fingerprinting method, combin
ed with mineral speciation and ''bioavailability'' tests, approaches w
hich have in the past been largely applied to mineral exploration. Hig
h precision lead isotope ratio measurements and lead contents were det
ermined by thermal ionization mass spectrometry on biological samples
(blood, urine) and environmental samples from 27 families, encompassin
g 60 children, 41 female adults, and 17 male adults. Environmental sam
ples analyzed (not from every household) included soils, gutter sweepi
ngs, ceiling dust, vacuum cleaner dust, long-term dust, surface dust w
ipes, external and internal air, food, water, and gasoline. Sources of
lead have been identified in the blood of children, using lead isotop
es, with dominant contributions from the Broken Hill orebody, but with
individual cases having a dominant source of lead from gasoline or pa
int. Nevertheless, of 28 children with a blood lead level (Pb(B)) > 15
mug/dl, approximately 30 percent have more than 50 percent of their P
b(B) from sources other than orebody lead. Female adults generally hav
e a low Pb(B), <10 mug/dl, and the source of their lead is attributed
to air (gasoline, orebody), food, and water. The source of lead in mal
e adults can usually be correlated with their occupation, depending on
whether it is related to high risk activities, such as mining (domina
ntly orebody lead) or service stations (gasoline lead), or ''nonexpose
d.'' Knowledge of the occupation and lead isotope composition in the f
ather's blood is an important indicator of lead pathways. Other potent
ial sources of lead, such as food and water, have lead contents too lo
w to be significant contributors to lead levels in most children. Scan
ning electron microscopy (energy dispersive X-ray analyses) identified
the most common lead species in soils and dusts to be composed of a c
omplex Pb,Fe,Mn,Ca,Al,Si,O material with rare galena in houses close t
o the central mining activity. These lead complexes are quite differen
t from ones found in other mining communities, such as those found in
the United States, where the lead may be in less soluble forms such as
pyromorphite or encapsulated in less soluble anglesite, pyrite, or qu
artz. Approximations of bioavailability (more correctly, solubility) w
ere made by leaching, with 0.1 M HCl for 2 hr at 37-degrees-C, bulk (u
nsized) and a critical size fraction of -53 + 38 mum. The 0.1 M HCl ex
tracts 33 to 61 percent (mean = 47 +/- 10%, n = 7) of the total leacha
ble lead from gutter sweepings, from 41 to 84 percent (mean = 60 +/- 1
0%, n = 10) from soils, and 17 to > 100 percent (mean = 47 +/- 38%, n
= 5) from vacuum cleaner dusts. Thus the currently suggested amounts o
f approximately 100 mg/d ingested soil (dirt) and dust for a Broken Hi
ll child can readily account for the elevated lead levels compared wit
h the amounts for children in many other mining communities. Based on
these investigations it is possible to construct a flow sheet of sourc
es and pathways for the lead into humans at Broken Hill on which to ba
se correct remedial actions.