P. Cacoub et al., ANTICARDIOLIPIN, ANTI-BETA(2)-GLYCOPROTEIN-I, AND ANTINUCLEOSOME ANTIBODIES IN HEPATITIS-C VIRUS-INFECTION AND MIXED CRYOGLOBULINEMIA, Journal of rheumatology, 24(11), 1997, pp. 2139-2144
Objective. To investigate anticardiolipin antibodies (aCL), anti-beta(
2)-glycoprotein I (anti-beta(2)GPI), and antinucleosome antibodies in
patients with hepatitis C virus (HCV) with or without mixed cryoglobul
inemia. aCL can appear in infectious diseases, but are not then associ
ated with thrombotic events. Antibodies directed to beta(2)GPI, a co-f
actor of aCL, have been said to be associated with the presence of ''a
utoimmune'' aCL, About 50% Of cases of essential mixed cryoglobulinemi
a are associated with HCV infection, High prevalence of autoantibodies
directed to nuclear antigens has been found in HCV infection but the
prevalence of antibody to nucleosome has not yet been reported, Method
s. Group 1: 29 patients with chronic HCV infection and mixed cryoglobu
linemia. Group 2: 17 patients with chronic HCV infection but without m
ixed cryoglobulinemia, To analyze the possible effect of mixed cryoglo
bulinemia itself on aCL production, we also studied 22 patients with e
ssential mixed cryoglobulinemia and no HCV infection (Group 3). In add
ition, 96 healthy blood donors were used as a control group (Group 4).
Mixed cryoglobulinemia was detected by immunofixation. Anti-HCV antib
odies were detected by 3rd generation tests. aCL, anti-beta(2)GPI, and
antinucleosome antibodies were detected by ELISA. In patients with mi
xed cryoglobulinemia, we also looked for aCL separately in cryoprecipi
tate and in serum after extraction of mixed cryoglobulins to investiga
te a possible ''capture'' of aCL in the cryoprecipitate. Results. IgG
aCL were more frequently found in patients with HCV than in controls [
9/46 (20%) vs 2/96 (2%); p < 0.001]. The prevalence of aCL was similar
in patients with HCV with or without mixed cryoglobulinemia (6/29 vs
3/17; p = NS). No patient with positive aCL had anti-beta(2)GPI, anti-
nucleosome antibodies, thrombotic events, or thrombocytopenia, IgG aCL
were more frequent in patients with mixed cryoglobulinemia, whatever
their status for HCV infection, than in subjects without mixed cryoglo
bulinemia [8/51 (16%) vs 5/113 (4%); p < 0.02]. The prevalence of aCL
was similar in patients with type II or type III mixed cryoglobulinemi
a. When we looked for aCL separately in serum and in cryoprecipitate,
we did not find aCL in cryoprecipitate. In patients with HCV, the prev
alence of aCL was not different whether patients were treated or not w
ith interferon alpha. Conclusion. IgG aCL are frequently found in pati
ents with HCV regardless of status for mixed cryoglobulinemia. These a
CL have the characteristics of infection related aCL, low titer, absen
ce of thrombotic events, and absence of anti-beta(2)GPI. The high prop
ortion of aCL in patients with mixed cryoglobulinemia compared to thos
e without, and the absence of antinucleosome antibodies, suggest that
these aCL may be secondary to endothelial damage induced by mixed cryo
globulinemia or HCV itself, rather than to nonspecific polyclonal lymp
hocyte activation.