A. Fieldstone et al., FOOD PREFERENCES IN PRADER-WILLI-SYNDROME, NORMAL-WEIGHT AND OBESE CONTROLS, International journal of obesity, 21(11), 1997, pp. 1046-1052
OBJECTIVE: The aim of this work was to assess the specific food type (
high carbohydrate, high fat, high protein) preference profiles of indi
viduals with Prader-Willi syndrome (PWS), obese controls and normal we
ight individuals. DESIGN: Subjects tasted a food predominantly high in
carbohydrate, a food predominantly high in protein and a food predomi
nantly high in fat over repeated trials and indicated their most prefe
rred, second preferred and least preferred foods. Specific items teste
d on a given trial were counterbalanced in a black randomized fashion.
SUBJECTS: These were 12 individuals with Prader-Willi syndrome, 12 ma
tched obese controls (obese, but otherwise normal) and 14 normal weigh
t subjects. MEASUREMENTS: The basic data were expressed as a proportio
n of each food type selected as most preferred over the total 27 trial
s. RESULTS: PWS subjects preferred high carbohydrate foods over high p
rotein foods and high protein foods over high fat foods. These subject
s demonstrated a statistically reliable difference in preference for h
igh carbohydrate foods over high fat foods. However, normal weight and
obese control subjects demonstrated no difference in food preferences
. The only significant between-group comparisons were between PWS subj
ects and obese controls, with the PWS group showing a significantly gr
eater preference for high carbohydrate foods than obese controls. CONC
LUSIONS: The obesity of PWS was shown to have a significant and distin
ctly different food preference profile from normal weight and obese co
ntrols. The differences in food preference between the obese PWS and n
on-PWS subjects is in accord with the growing recognition of functiona
l subgroups within the obese population, that may have not only differ
ing underlying etiologies, but also distinct behavioral profiles of in
gestion.