El. Johnson et al., EFFECT OF SOIL-PH ON MINERAL ELEMENT CONCENTRATIONS OF 2 ERYTHROXYLUMSPECIES, Journal of plant nutrition, 20(11), 1997, pp. 1503-1515
Erythroxylum coca var. coca Lam. (E. coca) and Erythroxylum novogranat
ense var. novogranatense (Morris) Hieron (E. n. novogranatense) are tw
o of four Erythroxylum species grown in the tropics of South America f
or cultural medicines and the alkaloid benzoylmethylecgonine. In a pub
lished study of biomass production over a soil pH range of 3.5 to 7.0,
E. coca grew best at a pH equal to and below 5.5, and E. n. novograna
tense grew best within the pH range of 4.7 to 6.0. Erythroxylum coca w
as tentatively classified as more tolerant to metal toxicities [alumin
um (Al) and manganese (Mn)] than E, n. novogranatense, however, concen
tration patterns of mineral elements for E. coca and E. n. novogranate
nse tissue have not been reported, nor have the mechanisms of differen
tial acid-soil-tolerance been elucidated. In the current study, the ef
fects of soil pH on concentrations of Al, calcium(Ca), copper (Cu), ir
on (Fe), potassium (K), magnesium (Mg), Mn, and zinc (Zn) in leaves, s
tems, and roots were investigated. At pH 3.5, roots of both species ac
cumulated high concentrations of Al that decreased as soil pH increase
d, however, there was no pH x species interaction. The highest concent
ration of Ca was found in the leaves of both species, however, E. coca
accumulated more Ca as soil pH increased than did E. n. novogranatens
e. Manganese and Zn levels were highest in roots of both species (E. c
oca and E. n. novogranatense); levels in all tissues decreased with in
creasing pH. Manganese concentration was highest in roots of E. coca a
nd Zn concentration was highest in tissues off. n. novogranatense. Cop
per, Fe, K, and Mg levels were erratic with increasing pH, indicating
that sufficient amounts of these nutrients are acquired at low pH leve
ls. Root concentrations of Fe and K in E. coca increased markedly betw
een pH 3.5 and 4.7. At pH 3.5, E. coca demonstrated no symptoms of min
eral deficiency and/or toxicity, however, chlorosis, leaf distortion a
nd root atrophy were prevalent at pH 6.5 and 7.0. By contrast, E. n. n
ovogranatense demonstrated diminished growth and root atrophy at soil
pH 3.5, whereas at pH 6.5 and 7.0, although biomass production was red
uced, no symptoms of mineral deficiency and/or toxicity were present.
The species obviously behave differentially at pH extremes and E. coca
appears to be most tolerant of extremely acid soils; the two species
may also differ in mineral sensitivities between the species at higher
pH levels. Erythroxylum coca may compete more effectively with Al for
Ca binding sites within the root, and may have greater internal toler
ance of Mn, compared with E. n. novogranatense.