J. Meinhart et al., 8 YEARS OF CLINICAL ENDOTHELIAL-CELL TRANSPLANTATION - CLOSING THE GAP BETWEEN PROSTHETIC GRAFTS AND VEIN GRAFTS, ASAIO journal, 43(5), 1997, pp. 515-521
After years of in vitro studies and non human primate implantations, t
he authors commenced their clinical program of autologous in vitro end
othelialization of polytetrafluoroethylene (ePTFE) grafts in 1989. Bas
ed on the successful 3 year results of a pilot study (Phase I) with 49
patients (1:2 randomization, assigning 33 patients to the endothelial
ized group and 16 to the control group), the authors offered in vitro
endothelialized grafts to all patients who did not have a suitable sap
henous vein available from tune 1993 onward (Phase II). Another 72 pat
ients received 81 successfully endothelialized ePTFE grafts in this se
cond phase of the transplantation program. In the Phase I randomized t
rial, the Kaplan-Meier survivorship analysis showed a primary 3 year p
atency rate of 84.7% for endothelialized grafts and 55.4% for control
grafts. After 5 years, it was 73.8% for the endothelialized group and
20.8% for the controls. At the end of the 7 year follow-up period, the
primary patency rate for endothelialized grafts remained high at 73.8
%, whereas that for the control grafts dropped to zero (log-rank test;
p = 0.001 and Wilcoxon test; p = 0.003). The subsequent Phase II rout
ine clinical implantation of endothelialized ePTFE grafts showed a 3 1
/2 year primary patency rate of 72.9% for all femoropopliteal reconstr
uctions. The authors' overall 7 year follow-up with endothelialized fe
moropopliteal ePTFE grafts (n = 108) shows a patency of 66.0%. When pr
etreated with fibronectin (n = 43), the 7 year patency was 72.1%. In t
he above-knee group, the 7 year patency for fibronectin treated grafts
was as high as 75.8% (n = 36). After 8 years of clinical endothelial
cell transplantation, the authors conclude that in vitro endothelializ
ation of ePTFE grafts results in a patency rate of arterial prostheses
comparable with that of vein grafts.