Fb. Taub, UNIQUE INFORMATION CONTRIBUTED BY MULTISPECIES SYSTEMS - EXAMPLES FROM THE STANDARDIZED AQUATIC MICROCOSM, Ecological applications, 7(4), 1997, pp. 1103-1110
Single-species toxicity tests are inadequate to predict the effects of
chemicals in ecological communities although they provide data on the
relative toxicity of different chemicals, and on the relative sensiti
vity of different organisms. Only multispecies studies can provide dem
onstrations of: (1) indirect trophic-level effects, including increase
d abundances of species via increased food supply through reduced comp
etition or reduced predation; (2) compensatory shifts within a trophic
level; (3) responses to chemicals within the context of seasonal patt
erns that modify water chemistry and birth and death rates of populati
ons; (4) chemical transformations by some organisms having effects on
other organisms; and (5) persistence of parent and transformation prod
ucts. Multispecies laboratory studies, such as the Standardized Aquati
c Microcosm, have much to offer, with advantages of statistical power,
speed of analyses, demonstrated reproducibility among laboratories, a
nd modest expense (compared to held studies). The use of a chemically
defined sediment facilitates the potential extraction of parent and tr
ansformation products by minimizing the problem of unextractable resid
ues. The absence of fish prevents the potential elimination of zooplan
kton if fish predation exceeds production. Standardized Aquatic Microc
osms also offer a wealth of analytical tools, including rapid statisti
cal analyses, a mathematical model (MICMOD), and artificial intelligen
ce methodologies.