Jy. Pontailler et al., STORMS DRIVE SUCCESSIONAL DYNAMICS IN NATURAL FORESTS - A CASE-STUDY IN FONTAINEBLEAU FOREST (FRANCE), Forest ecology and management, 98(1), 1997, pp. 1-15
The biological reserves at Fontainebleau forest are almost unique with
in the lowlands of western Europe, having been preserved for at least
four centuries. This study, performed by the same team for 30 yr, look
s closely at the behaviour of two plots of about 35 ha, largely domina
ted by European beech (Fagus sylvatica L.). Since the turn of the cent
ury, several fierce storms have followed one another at fairly regular
intervals (25 yi). The consequences of the two latter storms (1967 an
d 1990), together with the evolution between them, were examined. The
immediate consequence was a violent disturbance, eliminating or mutila
ting healthy trees as well as senescent ones, and opening gaps of vari
able sizes in the canopy. During the quiet period between the two hurr
icanes, a healing phase was observed, characterised by the extension o
f crowns, the development of shade-repressed saplings and/or a regener
ation of seedlings. Considering the former evolution, several indices
are commented upon, thus making a reconstitution possible. As a conclu
sion, storms play a major role in the cyclic dynamics of unmanaged for
ests, taking them away from a steady state they nearly never reach. A
25-yr recurrence period was observed, being short compared with a tree
lifetime (200-300 yr). However, at the scale of a plot, even strong s
torms were unable to upset the population structure, mostly causing on
ly small gaps. in these conditions, spreading out or survival of woody
species other than shade-tolerant beech is questionable (a modest pre
sence of hornbeam [Carpinus betulus] and holly excepted). One may not
reject totally this hypothesis: storms of an outstanding intensity or
climate change may affect beech supremacy. Since previous papers on th
is subject were published in French only, the authors took the liberty
of mentioning by places some results that are not fully original. (C)
1997 Elsevier Science B.V.