Lc. Hanson et al., WHAT IS WRONG WITH END-OF-LIFE CARE - OPINIONS OF BEREAVED FAMILY MEMBERS, Journal of the American Geriatrics Society, 45(11), 1997, pp. 1339-1344
OBJECTIVE: To describe family perceptions of I:are at the end of life.
METHODS: In a representative sample of older people who died from chr
onic diseases, family members were interviewed about satisfaction with
treatment intensity, decision-making, and symptom relief in the last
month of life, and gave suggestions to improve care. RESULTS: Intervie
ws were completed with 461 family members, 80% of those contacted. The
y reported that 9% of decedents received CPR, 11% ventilator support,
and 24% intensive care during their last month of life. Family members
could not recall a discussion of treatment decisions in 23% of cases.
Presence or absence of a living will did not affect the likelihood of
no discussion (22% vs 24%, P = .85). Family informants desired more t
reatment to sustain life in 8% of deaths. They or the decedent wanted
treatments doctors did not recommend in 6% of deaths but refused recom
mended therapies in 18% of deaths. They believed more care to relieve
pain or other symptoms was indicated in 18% of deaths. Asked to make p
ositive or negative comments about any aspect of terminal care, 91% of
comments on hospice were positive. Nursing home care received the sma
llest proportion of positive comments (51%). Family members recommenda
tions to improve end of life care emphasized better communication (44%
), greater access to physicians' time (17%), and better pain managemen
t (10%). CONCLUSION: Bereaved family members are generally satisfied w
ith life-sustaining treatment decisions. Their primary concerns are fa
ilures in communication and pain control. Discussions that focus on sp
ecific treatment decisions may not satisfy the real needs of dying pat
ients and their families.