G. Perugi et al., THE CLINICAL IMPACT OF BIPOLAR AND UNIPOLAR AFFECTIVE COMORBIDITY ON OBSESSIVE-COMPULSIVE DISORDER, Journal of affective disorders, 46(1), 1997, pp. 15-23
Previous studies on the comorbidity of Obsessive-Compulsive Disorder (
OCD) have largely focused on comorbidity with major depressive and anx
iety disorders. The present investigation deals with a more complex pa
ttern of comorbidity involving bipolarity. Indeed, in a consecutive se
ries of 315 OCD outpatients, 15.7% had such comorbidity (mostly with b
ipolar II disorder). Unlike non-bipolar OCD patients, these had a more
gradual onset of their OCD which, nonetheless, pursued a more episodi
c course with a greater number of concurrent major depressive episodes
. These bipolar OCD patients had a significantly higher rate of sexual
and religious obsessions, and a significantly lower rate of checking
rituals. OCD probands with non-bipolar major depressive comorbidity (3
4.8%) were then compared with the remainder of OCD. These 'unipolar' O
CD were older, had a more chronic course with hospitalizations and sui
cide attempts, had greater comorbidity with generalized anxiety disord
er and caffeine abuse; finally, they were more likely to have aggressi
ve obsessions and those with a philosophical, superstitious or bizarre
content. Our data suggest that when comorbidity occurs with bipolar a
nd unipolar affective disorders it has a differential impact on the cl
inical characteristics, comorbidity and course of OCD. We submit that
the presence of major depression in OCD is incidental, as OCD in such
cases dominates the course and dictates treatment choice. By contrast,
when bipolar and obsessive-compulsive disorders co-exist, bipolarity
should take precedence in diagnosis, course and treatment consideratio
ns. (C) 1997 Elsevier Science B.V.