DEVELOPMENT OF VALIDATED DISEASE-ACTIVITY AND DAMAGE INDEXES FOR THE JUVENILE IDIOPATHIC INFLAMMATORY MYOPATHIES .1. PHYSICIAN, PARENT, ANDPATIENT GLOBAL ASSESSMENTS
Lg. Rider et al., DEVELOPMENT OF VALIDATED DISEASE-ACTIVITY AND DAMAGE INDEXES FOR THE JUVENILE IDIOPATHIC INFLAMMATORY MYOPATHIES .1. PHYSICIAN, PARENT, ANDPATIENT GLOBAL ASSESSMENTS, Arthritis and rheumatism, 40(11), 1997, pp. 1976-1983
Objective. To determine the reliability, content validity, and respons
iveness of physician global assessments of disease activity and damage
in the juvenite idiopathic inflammatory myopathies (IIM), and to inve
stigate concordance among physician, parent, and patient global rating
s. Methods. Sixteen pediatric rheumatologists rated 10 juvenile IIM pa
per patient cases far global disease activity and damage, and assessed
the importance of 51 clinical and laboratory parameters in formulatin
g their global assessments, Then, 117 juvenile IIM patients were enrol
led in a protocol to examine the relationship between Likert and visua
l analog scale global assessments, their sensitivity to change, and th
e comparability of physician, parent, and patient global ratings. Resu
lts. Pediatric rheumatologists demonstrated excellent interrater relia
bility in their global assessments of juvenile IIM disease activity an
d damage (97.7% and 94.7% agreement among raters, respectively), and a
greed on a core set of clinical parameters in formulating their judgme
nts. Likert scale ratings correlated with those on a visual analog sca
le, and both were comparable in responsiveness (standardized response
means -0.56 for disease activity, 0.02 [Likert] and 0.14 [visual analo
g] for damage, measured over 8 months). Parent global ratings of disea
se activity correlated with physician assessments, but were not coline
ar (Spearman's correlation [r] = 0.41-0.45). Patient global disease ac
tivity assessments correlated with those done by parents (r = 0.57-0.8
4) and physicians (r = 0.37-0.63), but demonstrated less responsivenes
s (standardized response means -0.21 and -0.12, respectively, over 8 m
onths). Conclusion. Physician global assessments of juvenile IIM disea
se activity and damage demonstrated high interrater reliability and we
re shown to be comprehensive measures. Both physician and parent disea
se activity assessments should be considered valuable as quantitative
measures for evaluating therapeutic responses in juvenile IIM patients
.