A. Dupre et Cs. Beck, HOW CAN I PUT THIS - EXAGGERATED SELF-DISPARAGEMENT AS ALIGNMENT STRATEGY DURING PROBLEMATIC DISCLOSURES BY PATIENTS TO DOCTORS, Qualitative health research, 7(4), 1997, pp. 487-503
This article explores how patients engage in problematic disclosures t
o their physician. Dialogue from medical encounters suggests that pati
ents sometimes use exaggerated self-disparagement to bid for a physici
an's forgiveness and reassurance. Grounded in work on conversational f
raming and alignment, this study documents the conversational mechanis
m of overclaiming. Overclaims function like disclaimers or accounts, b
ut rather than disclaiming responsibility for art action with potentia
lly negative consequences, the speaker seems to claim disproportionate
responsibility for it. In the conversations studied, such bids pay of
f with emphatic compliments and reassurance. Overclaiming facilitates
a shift from the primary frame of a medical encounter to a secondary f
rame that focuses on the nature of the overclaim rather than the natur
e of the violation. It is suggested that overclaims are used to elicit
more-than-usual reassurance, to save face, and to preserve conversati
onal alignment.