LONG-TERM EFFICIENCY OF HOME NASAL MASK VENTILATION IN PATIENTS WITH DIFFUSE BRONCHIECTASIS AND SEVERE CHRONIC RESPIRATORY-FAILURE - A CASE-CONTROL STUDY
D. Benhamou et al., LONG-TERM EFFICIENCY OF HOME NASAL MASK VENTILATION IN PATIENTS WITH DIFFUSE BRONCHIECTASIS AND SEVERE CHRONIC RESPIRATORY-FAILURE - A CASE-CONTROL STUDY, Chest, 112(5), 1997, pp. 1259-1266
The aim of this study was to evaluate long-term efficacy and tolerance
of nasal mask ventilation (NMV) in a comparative case-control study,
Fourteen patients with diffuse bronchiectasis and severe chronic respi
ratory failure (CRF), treated by long-term oxygen-therapy (LTO) and NM
V, were case matched with 14 patients with diffuse bronchiectasis and
severe CRF treated with only LTO, Patients and control subjects were c
ompared based on the following parameters: blood gases, FEV1, vital ca
pacity, hospitalizations, and survival, Symptoms, Karnofsky function s
core, and clinical evolution were also monitored in patients, Three su
bgroups may be identified according to outcome: two early deaths (subg
roup I), six: patients with initial improvement and subsequent deterio
ration (subgroup 2), and six patients whose conditions remained improv
ed for >2 years (subgroup 3), PaO2 decrease slope was slighter in this
last subgroup than subgroup 2, The days of hospitalization were signi
ficantly reduced after institution of NMV in the patient group, Compar
ison between patients and control subjects did not show any difference
on PaO2 evolution and on the overall median survival (46 and 40 month
s in NMV and control group, respectively), Long-term tolerance and com
pliance remained satisfactory for 11 patients, These results suggest t
hat NMV is feasible as a long-term home treatment in patients with dif
fuse bronchiectasis. Although our results may have failed to prove a l
ong-term efficiency on the course of blood gases and survival, a benef
icial effect is observed with reduction of hospitalizations and improv
ement of functional status, This study warrants further investigation,
in a prospective series, with a larger number of patients.