Sm. Heah et al., HARTMANNS PROCEDURE VS. ABDOMINOPERINEAL RESECTION FOR PALLIATION OF ADVANCED LOW RECTAL-CANCER, Diseases of the colon & rectum, 40(11), 1997, pp. 1313-1317
In managing advanced low rectal adenocarcinomas in medically fit patie
nts, surgical resection offers the best palliation. Tenesmus, bleeding
per rectum, sacral pain, and sciatic pain are common complaints, whic
h are not relieved by radiotherapy or fulguration. The most appropriat
e resection, however, remains controversial. Abdominoperineal resectio
n is faster and simpler to perform but leaves behind a perineal wound
with associated complications. Hartmann's procedure requires adequate
mobilization below the tumor and may be technically more demanding but
avoids a perineal wound. Therefore, an analysis of outcome in patient
s treated by Hartmann's procedure vs. abdominoperineal resection was m
ade. METHOD: Fifty-four symptomatic patients with advanced rectal aden
ocarcinoma arising within a median of 5 (range, 4-8) cm from the anal
verge treated between June 1989 and October 1995 were studied. Twenty-
eight patients (17 males; mean age, 67.6 +/- 10.3 years) had Hartmann'
s procedure, and 26 patients (12 females; mean age, 68.8 +/- 8.3 years
) were treated by abdominoperineal resection. Mean followup was 23.5 m
onths (+/-17.5) and 18.6 months (+/-12.9) in Hartmann's procedure and
abdominoperineal groups, respectively. RESULTS: Mean operative time wa
s 138.4 +/- 26.7 minutes for Hartmann's procedure group and 124.6 +/-
27.1 minutes for the abdominoperineal resection group (P > 0.05; not s
ignificant). Postoperatively, Hartmann's procedure group started oral
intake at a mean of 2.3 days, and stomas were functioning at a mean of
3.1 days compared with 2.6 days for oral intake and 3 days for stoma
functioning in the abdominoperineal resection group. Hartmann's proced
ure group was ambulant after a mean of 2.4 days vs a mean of 3.2 days
in the abdominoperineal resection group. Postoperative abdominal wound
infection occurred in 18 and 19 percent, respectively, in Hartmann's
procedure and abdominoperineal resection groups. Forty-six percent of
patients had perineal wound sepsis, and 38 percent had perineal wound
pain in the abdominoperineal resection group. These complications were
absent in Hartmann's procedure group. Postoperative stay was similar
in both groups. CONCLUSION: We conclude;hat Hartmann's procedure offer
s superior palliation compared with abdominoperineal resection because
it provides good symptomatic control without any perineal wound compl
ications and pain.