N. Jorgensen et al., SEMEN ANALYSIS PERFORMED BY DIFFERENT LABORATORY TEAMS - AN INTERVARIATION STUDY, International journal of andrology, 20(4), 1997, pp. 201-208
Some recent studies have indicated that sperm concentration has decrea
sed during the last 50 years. However, comparisons between laboratorie
s have revealed that geographical differences seem to exist and that a
ny decrease may not be global. One point of criticism concerning compa
rison of results from different laboratories has been that some of the
discrepancies detected could reflect the lack of standardized methods
used in the different laboratories. Four teams, each consisting of on
e physician and one technician from groups which have recently publish
ed data on semen quality, met in order to evaluate the variability bet
ween their laboratories on semen analysis. Twenty-six fresh semen samp
les from unselected men were analysed. The groups analysed the samples
according to the normal practice in their laboratories, using their o
wn equipment. The variation between laboratories was estimated through
a random effects model. For sperm concentration and semen volume asse
ssment a remarkable consistency between laboratories was detected, in
contrast to the very considerable interindividual variation. For sperm
motility and morphology assessments interlaboratory consistency was m
uch poorer. In conclusion, evaluation of sperm motility and morphology
characteristics requires further standardization in order to achieve
comparable data from different laboratories. However, semen volume and
sperm concentration are characteristics which can be compared reliabl
y between laboratories, when similar methodologies are used.