H. Izawa et al., ADRENERGIC CONTROL OF THE FORCE-FREQUENCY AND RELAXATION-FREQUENCY RELATIONS IN PATIENTS WITH HYPERTROPHIC CARDIOMYOPATHY, Circulation, 96(9), 1997, pp. 2959-2968
Background Exercise-induced enhancement of the force frequency and rel
axation-frequency relations has been studied in conscious animals but
not in intact diseased human hearts. Methods and Results We evaluated
left ventricular (LV) isovolumic contraction (dP/dt(max)) and relaxati
on (tau) during atrial pacing and dynamic exercise in 13 patients with
nonobstructive hypertrophic cardiomyopathy (HCM) and 7 control subjec
ts to investigate the influence of exercise on the force-frequency and
relaxation-frequency relations. Group A consisted of 6 patients in wh
om the heart rate (HR)-dP/dt(max) relation was markedly enhanced durin
g exercise (88+/-30%) compared with during pacing (34+/-15%). Group B
consisted of 7 patients in whom the HR-dP/dt(max) relation showed simi
lar enhancement during exercise (28+/-7%) and atrial pacing (28+/-11%)
. There was no difference in the HR-tau (derivative method [TD] and pr
essure half-time method [T-1/2]) relation between pacing and exercise
in groups A and B. Both the mean maximal wall thickness and the hypert
rophy score in group B were greater than in group A (27+/-5 versus 19/-2 mm and 7+/-1 versus 5+/-1 points, respectively; both P<.01). There
was no difference in the LV peak systolic pressure, end-diastolic pre
ssure, or the plasma level of catecholamines at baseline, at 50 W of e
xercise, and at peak pacing between groups A and B. The HR-dP/dt(max),
relation in the control group was markedly enhanced during exercise (
80+/-27%) compared with during pacing (32+/-14%). The HR-tau relation
in the control group was enhanced during exercise (TD, 35+/-9%; T-1/2
34+/-8%) compared with during pacing (TD, 12+/-7%; T-1/2 14+/-7%). Con
clusions Exercise-induced enhancement of the relaxation-frequency rela
tion was inhibited in all HCM patients, regardless of the degree of LV
hypertrophy. The patients without exercise-induced enhancement of the
force-frequency relation had more severe LV hypertrophy than the pati
ents with the enhancement, indicating that the adrenergic control of t
he force-frequency relation may, at least in part, depend on the sever
ity of LV hypertrophy or the stage of HCM.