J. Braine et C. Dupraz, DEEP CO OBSERVATIONS OF DOMINANT CLUSTER GALAXIES WITH REPORTED COOLING FLOWS, Astronomy and astrophysics, 283(2), 1994, pp. 407-416
X-ray observations of galaxy clusters have been interpreted as reveali
ng massive cooling flows in many of them. Whatever the final sink (sta
rs, planets, etc.), the cooling gas is bound to pass through a molecul
ar phase. We have used the IRAM 30 m millimeter-wave telescope to obse
rve eight cluster dominant galaxies with high reported gas inflow rate
s in the (CO)-C-12 (1-0) and (CO)-C-12 (2-1) lines. Despite low noise
levels, none of the galaxies were detected in either line with 1 sigma
limits to M(H2) ranging between 4 10(7) and 1.3 10(9) M.. These value
s are two orders of magnitude below values expected from the reported
accretion rates (often M greater-than-or-equal-to 100 M. yr-1) and the
measured star-formation time in spirals and ellipticals (tau(SF) appr
oximately 1 Gyr). Even supposing that the whole process of star format
ion - from recombination of ionized gas into atoms and molecules to cl
oud gravitational condensation - is governed by the collapse time (app
roximately 4 10(7) yr) and that only part of the cold gas is included
in the IRAM beam, our detection limits rule out the high values of M p
roposed by the ''standard model'' of cooling flows by a factor 5 on av
erage. These results add to the other observational and theoretical pr
oblems faced by the standard interpretation of X-ray data. We conclude
that a revision of the traditional picture appears necessary.