The hypothesis that a low concordance rate in monozygotic (MZ) twins w
ith systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE) may be accounted for by differe
nces in X-chromosome inactivation was examined. Five MZ twin pairs, fo
ur discordant and one concordant, were recruited, zygosity confirmed b
y DNA fingerprinting, and their pattern of X-chromosome inactivation i
n DNA samples prepared from peripheral blood and buccal cells were exa
mined. X-chromosome inactivation was assessed by the methylation statu
s of the CpG region near trinucleotide repeats in exon 1 of the androg
en receptor gene on X-chromosome after digestion with the methylation-
sensitive enzyme HpaII or HhaI and PCR amplification. X-chromosome ina
ctivation patterns were found to be the same between affected and non-
affected twins in all four discordant twin pairs, with random patterns
in two pairs and skewed patterns in the others. The concordant twins
demonstrated the same random patterns. X-chromosome inactivation was a
lso examined from buccal smear DNA and shown to have the same pattern
as that noted from peripheral blood DNA in one informative twin pair.
Differences in X-chromosome inactivation patterns were not observed in
these five MZ twin pairs. The results could not support the hypothesi
s that differences in X-chromosome inactivation is the mechanism accou
nting for the low concordance rate noted in MZ twins with SLE.