Jp. Bryan et M. Nelson, TESTING FOR ANTIBODY TO HEPATITIS-A TO DECREASE THE COST OF HEPATITIS-A PROPHYLAXIS WITH IMMUNE GLOBULIN OR HEPATITIS-A VACCINES, Archives of internal medicine, 154(6), 1994, pp. 663-668
Background: The introduction of new vaccines to prevent hepatitis A in
fection raises the question of the cost of these vaccines relative to
immune globulin when short-term protection against hepatitis A is requ
ired. Since the prevalence of hepatitis A antibodies (anti-HAV) in the
US population increases rapidly with age, testing for anti-HAV may de
crease the cost of vaccination programs.Methods: A cost-analysis model
was developed that incorporates the cost of immune globulin or hepati
tis A vaccine, the number of doses of vaccine, the cost of testing for
anti-HAV in either commercial or public-sector laboratories, and the
prevalence of anti-HAV in the general population by age. Results: In c
omparison with hepatitis A vaccines, with expected costs between $10 a
nd $25 per dose, use of immune globulin for postexposure prophylaxis o
r preexposure shortterm (less than or equal to 6 months) prophylaxis i
s much less expensive for all age groups. Testing for anti-HAV does no
t significantly diminish the cost of immune globulin regimens. In cont
rast, if anti-HAV testing is performed in a public-sector laboratory a
t $10 per test, and hepatitis A vaccine costs $10 per dose, testing re
duces vaccination costs in those 40 years of age or older for a two-do
se vaccine regimen and in those 30 years of age or older for a three-d
ose regimen. At the other end of the spectrum, if vaccine costs $35 pe
r dose, commercial testing for anti-HAN at $25 per person reduces the
costs in those 30 years of age or older if either a two- or three-dose
regimen is elected. However, vaccine savings are realized in those 10
years and older if public-sector testing is performed and three doses
of vaccine at $35 per dose are utilized. In an intermediate scenario
of public-sector testing and vaccines costing $25 per dose, the cost w
ould also be reduced in those 30 years old or older. Conclusions: Test
ing for anti-HAV in frequent travelers, international government, busi
ness, and volunteer workers, military personnel, etc, may be an effect
ive means of decreasing costs of hepatitis A prevention.