Pa. Minugh et al., ANALYSIS OF ALCOHOL-USE CLUSTERS AMONG SUBCRITICALLY INJURED EMERGENCY DEPARTMENT PATIENTS, Academic emergency medicine, 4(11), 1997, pp. 1059-1067
Objectives: 1) To cluster patients according to self-reported drinking
patterns using cluster analysis; 2) to externally validate clustered
groups on variables related to drinking but not used in the cluster an
alysis; and 3) to use the clustered patients' responses to alcohol con
sumption questions to develop a brief screening tool emergency physici
ans can use to identify patients in need of referral or intervention r
elated to potentially hazardous alcohol consumption. Methods: A self-r
eport battery was administered to 95 subcritically injured patients. P
atients also were saliva alcohol-tested upon arrival to the ED. Using
the patients' self-reported quantity, frequency of alcohol consumption
, and frequency of having greater than or equal to 6 drinks on a drink
ing occasion, patients were categorized into 3 groups using cluster an
alysis. The 3 clusters were externally validated using injury-related
variables, alcohol-related consequences, and, the patients' reported r
eadiness to change drinking. A screening tool was developed using cuto
ff values reported by the patients' answers to drinking pattern questi
ons. Results: Fifty-nine patients were alcohol-negative, and 36 tested
alcohol-positive (i.e., >4 mmol/L [>20 mg/ dL]) or had elevated score
s on an alcohol problem screening instrument. Three distinct drinking
pattern clusters were found. Clusters were validated using discriminan
t function analysis and multivariate analyses of variance to confirm c
luster classifications. Steady and high-intensity drinkers reported mo
re alcohol-related negative consequences, and high-intensity drinkers
indicated they would consider changing their drinking. The screening t
ool correctly classified 97% of the patient sample into their respecti
ve clusters. Conclusions: Using the drinking pattern questions in the
clustering procedure was effective for grouping injured patients into
clusters that could be differentiated on other drinking-related variab
les. The resulting screening tool can be used in the ED setting to scr
een patients for further assessment and intervention. The readiness-to
-change results support the assertion that the injury event provides a
''teachable moment'' for subcritically injured patients whose injury
may be related to their alcohol consumption.