Jw. Essex et al., MONTE-CARLO SIMULATIONS FOR PROTEINS - BINDING AFFINITIES FOR TRYPSIN-BENZAMIDINE COMPLEXES VIA FREE-ENERGY PERTURBATIONS, JOURNAL OF PHYSICAL CHEMISTRY B, 101(46), 1997, pp. 9663-9669
Monte Carlo computer simulations have been performed in conjunction wi
th free-energy perturbation calculations to determine the relative bin
ding constants of four benzamidine inhibitors with trypsin. The protei
n backbone was constrained in the simulations, but sampling of the sid
e chains was allowed. The calculated free energies are very precise an
d are shown to yield closed thermodynamic cycles. The calculations cor
rectly predict p-aminobenzamidine to be the strongest inhibitor and gi
ve relative free energies of binding for p-methyl-and p-chlorobenzamid
ine in excellent agreement with experiment. The predicted overly weak
binding of the parent benzamidine is most likely due to a deficiency i
n the partial charges. The relative binding affinities are justified i
n terms of bulk-solvation arguments whereby the more polar inhibitors
are preferentially stabilized in water. The calculations demonstrate t
hat Monte Carlo computer simulations can be used to determine accurate
and precise relative binding constants for protein systems.