A. Gell, EXALTING THE KING AND OBSTRUCTING THE STATE - A POLITICAL INTERPRETATION OF ROYAL RITUAL IN BASTAR DISTRICT, CENTRAL INDIA, J ROY ANTHR, 3(3), 1997, pp. 433-450
This article offers an interpretation of tribalism in peninsular India
based on the political and economic characteristics of 'tribal' kingd
oms presided over by 'Hindu' kings. These kingdoms were markedly egali
tarian with a relatively direct relationship obtaining between the rul
er and his tribal subjects, unmediated by the layers of officialdom ch
aracteristic of neighbouring Hindu and Muslim kingdoms. This has been
typically explained as an evolutionary and historical consequence of '
primitivism' reinforced by physical isolation and the operation of exc
lusionary criteria by Hindu society. However, this article argues that
tribals have had more of an upper hand in negotiating status than is
hitherto suspected and employs Appadurai's concept of 'coercive subord
ination' to re-examine Hindu/tribal relations. By enacting an image of
themselves as volatile, forest-dwelling primitives, the tribals ensur
ed their relative freedom from state interference and inhibited the de
velopment of revenue-extracting institutions, in turn ensuring a state
weak in secular function but ritualistically exalted. This is demonst
rated by an analysis of the symbolism of the annual Dasara ritual in t
he old kingdom of Bastar, during which the Hindu king is subjected to
an 'abduction' by the tribal rabble before his confirmation as divine
ruler. Such rituals suggest a fresh interpretation be given to the so-
called tribal rebellions of 1876, 1910 and 1961 which occurred in the
kingdom of Bastar.