B. Hribar et al., DILUTE-SOLUTIONS OF HIGHLY ASYMMETRICAL ELECTROLYTES IN THE PRIMITIVEMODEL APPROXIMATION, Journal of molecular liquids, 73-4, 1997, pp. 277-289
The structure and thermodynamics of dilute solutions of a highly asymm
etric electrolyte were studied in the primitive model approximation. S
olutions of macroions and counterions in water with asymmetries in cha
rge of 10:1 (10:2) and of 20:1 (20:2), and asymmetries in size of 10:2
and of 15:2 were considered. The calculations apply to the concentrat
ion range where, an otherwise quite successful theory, the so-called h
ypernetted chain approximation, does not provide convergent results. T
he pair correlation functions and thermodynamic parameters were calcul
ated using recently developed two-density theory and the cluster expan
sion approach. The results of these two theories were compared with ne
w Monte Carlo simulations for the same model solution. The two-density
theory in the associated HNC approximation yields good agreement for
both structure and thermodynamics in solutions with monovalent counter
ions; i.e. for 10:1 and 20:1 electrolytes. The cluster expansion appro
ach, as used in this paper, is only applicable for low asymmetry in ch
arge and for dilute solutions of macroions and monovalent counterions.
Among the versions of the two-density theory studied here, only the m
ixed closure, i.e. associated MSA/HNC approximation, gives convergent
solutions for systems of macroions and divalent counterions. The agree
ment of this theory with the Monte Carlo results is only qualitative.