Thirteen different bioremediation products were evaluated for their ef
fectiveness in biodegrading petroleum hydrocarbons. All 13 products te
sted in this experiment were listed on the NCP product schedule. Of th
ese 13 products, 12 were bioaugmentation agents and one was a biostimu
lation agent. All the products were tested for toxicity levels initial
ly, using standardized protocols. The products were sampled and analyz
ed three times over a 28-day period for most-probable number (MPN) of
hydrocarbon degraders and total petroleum hydrocarbon as separate frac
tions. A subsample was analyzed for MPN, and the rest of the sample wa
s extracted and fractionated in total saturated petroleum hydrocarbons
(TsPH) and total aromatic petroleum hydrocarbons (TarPH). This experi
ment revealed that the petroleum hydrocarbons were biodegraded to an e
xtent significantly greater than that achieved by the naturally occurr
ing microorganisms. After 28 days, some products reduced the TsPH frac
tion to 60% of its initial weight and the TarPH fraction to 65%. Three
of the 13 products tested enhanced microbial degradation of the petro
leum to a degree significantly better than the nutrient control treatm
ents. Of these three products, only one showed a toxicity level below
that of the control treatment. (C) 1997 Elsevier Science Ltd.