K. Ritchie et al., ESTABLISHING THE LIMITS AND CHARACTERISTICS OF NORMAL AGE-RELATED COGNITIVE DECLINE, Revue d'epidemiologie et de sante publique, 45(5), 1997, pp. 373-381
Background : Research into ageing-related pathology relies not only on
exploration of disease aetiology, but also a clear understanding of t
he normal ageing process. The present study aims to examine the charac
teristics of elderly subjects who lie on the borderline between normal
and pathological ageing. Method : Cognitive functioning is examined u
sing computerized neuropsychometric assessment in a population of 833
normal elderly from which a cohort of 397 subjects with sub-clinical c
ognitive impairment are followed over three years. Subjects receive a
standardized neurological examination and ApoE genotypes are establish
ed. Results: Analysis of covariance revealed no cross-sectional age di
fferences for syntax comprehension (p = 0.19), articulation (p = 0.46)
, semantic matching (p = 0.12), reading (p 0.79), and implicit memory
(p = 0.21) while explicit memory, language skills and visuospatial ski
lls were found to deteriorate both in the cross-sectional age comparis
ons and across time. An overall intellectual ability factor; derived f
rom Principal Components Analysis, was found by regression to decline
principally in persons with low education, and a high initial Ie level
was observed to provide a protective effect over age 75. Persons with
higher levels of education show relative stability over time on langu
age and secondary memory tasks but deteriorate as rapidly as persons w
ith low education on visuospatial tasks. Five separate patterns of sub
-clinical cognitive deficit were isolated by cluster analysis. Two gro
ups, with differing clinical profiles (of which only one manifested th
e ApoE4 allele), were found to have an increased risk of developing se
nile dementia (OR = 4.4 and 3.9). A third group had a high prevalence
of depressive illness, and the remaining two showed very little change
. Conclusion : Ageing does not affect all cognitive functions uniforml
y; a high initial education level slowing rate of decline for certain
tasks. Separate patterns of cognitive change are observed in early sen
ile dementia, benign change and changes related to depressive illness.
Results suggest the need for more stringent selection of normal contr
ol groups.