Eb. Fisher et al., DIRECTIVE AND NONDIRECTIVE SOCIAL SUPPORT IN DIABETES MANAGEMENT, International journal of behavioral medicine, 4(2), 1997, pp. 131-144
Directive and Nondirective Support were distinguished (interrater agre
ement = 88.2%) through open-ended interviews completed by 60 adults wi
th Insulin Dependent Diabetes Mellitus. Supporting validity, the sum o
f both Directive and Nondirective Support was correlated with scores o
n the Interpersonal Support Evaluation List (ISEL; r=.36). Supporting
their distinction, Directive and Nondirective Support were inversely c
orrelated (r=-.26), and Directive but not Nondirective Support decreas
ed with age. Partial correlations controlled for general support, as m
easured by the ISEL, to examine the unique associations of Directive a
nd Nondirective Support. For those less than 30 years old, Nondirectiv
e Support was associated with better metabolic control (p=.004). For t
hose 30 or older, Directive Support appeared counterproductive, being
associated with greater negative mood (p=.02). Different types of supp
ort may play different roles in different areas of disease management
(e.g., metabolic control versus mood) and as a function of individual
characteristics such as age.