Dr. Porter et al., GREENBUG (HOMOPTERA, APHIDIDAE) BIOTYPES - SELECTED BY RESISTANT CULTIVARS OR PREADAPTED OPPORTUNISTS, Journal of economic entomology, 90(5), 1997, pp. 1055-1065
Future advances in wheat, Triticum aestivum L., and sorghum, Sorghum b
icolor (L.) Moench, resistance to greenbug, Schizaphis graminum (Ronda
ni), will likely come from introduction of resistance transgenes into
high-performance cultivars. First-generation resistance transgenes wil
l be single genes that impart antibiosis traits (similar to Bacillus t
huringiensis endotoxins in transgenic corn, Zea mays L.). This approac
h to pest management is incompatible with interpretations of simulatio
n models that predict that deployment of antibiosis resistance control
led by single genes drives the development of new, virulent pest bioty
pes. This dichotomy must be addressed if full advantage is to be taken
of the new, powerful tools of molecular biology for plant protection
against insects. In this study, the specific insect-plant interactions
of greenbugs on wheat and sorghum were examined to understand the rel
ationship between the deployment of plant resistance and the developme
nt of new greenbug biotypes. From this analysis, there was no relation
ship between the use of resistant wheat and the development of new gre
enbug biotypes. For sorghum, with only 3 of the 11 biotypes could ther
e be any correlation between the use of resistant hybrids and the deve
lopment of new biotypes. Even with these 3 biotypes, no clear cause-an
d-effect relationship was established. Based on analysis of these spec
ific insect-plant interactions, we propose that future plant resistanc
e efforts focus on the use of the most effective resistance genes, des
pite past predictions of what effect these genes may have on greenbug
population genetics.